Whenever I sit down to write any kind of story, one thing inevitably occurs. I make mistakes. No matter how extensive I outline my latest idea, or how much I thought about what I’m going to say, it’s never perfect when I first put it on the page.
And that’s okay. But it does bring up an important question. When do I start rewrites?
Different authors take different approaches to this. Some will keep chugging along until they’re done with the current draft, then when they’re ready for revisions, they’ll go back and make all the corrections they’ve spotted that need to be made before they start the revision process all over again. Others won’t move on from a chapter, or even a page, until they’ve reworked it to the point of perfection.
My method is a hybrid of the two. Or really, it’s mostly one, with a dash of the other.
When I sit down to write a draft of a story, particularly the first draft, I believe in keeping up the momentum of my writing. No matter how detailed I’ve been in the outlining process, it’s a tremendous feat for anyone to actually start composing their thoughts into a coherent story. Even though I’ve been doing this for decades, I’m deeply concerned if I brought my process to a complete stop to go back and fix something in an earlier chapter because I just realized it was wrong or thought of something better to say, I wouldn’t be able to get the train back on the tracks. I feel that this need for immediate perfection during your first go at composing a story is why so many authors don’t finish articulating their idea, essentially giving themselves writer’s block.
I do my best to cut down on the number of times I’m going to have to face this “Do I rewrite this” dilemma. One method I use is that extensive month’s long outlining process. I do my best to refine my plot, characters, and actions so that the formation and direction I want the story to take is crystal clear in my head. But bullet points don’t make a novel, so connecting all these ideas of what needs to be in a given chapter is still challenging, which is why I’m meticulous when I’m constructing the first draft. Numerous times, I’m holding down on the backspace key for an entire paragraph because I’m already editing my thoughts as I’m actually putting words to paper, screening out bad ideas and/or bad composition to eliminate the need for futures notes.
After finally settling on what makes the first draft, if I notice a mistake…err, let me start over. Because it’s not an if at all, it’s a when. And it’s not really a when, either. Rather, it’s every time I catch a mistake, the same notebook I’ve been using to outline the story now gets a new entry under the title “Notes & Revisions” and I mark down the chapter the latest edit is going to need to be made in, along with a shorthand of the change I’m going to want to make.
Now, in last week’s entry, I stated that I spent the most time writing page one of a new story, believing I need to get this right because the whole story is going to be built off of this foundation. Wouldn’t this suggest that I do backtrack and make revisions during my first draft of an idea?
Yes, it does. Which is where the dash of the other method comes in.
Sometimes, even after doing my best to sift out all the errors before they become part of the story, I’ll notice a couple paragraphs later that I’ve led myself down the wrong path. It might be difficult to comprehend how this could happen, after it’s been on my mind for months, after I’ve run my idea through the ringer again and again, and as I’m micromanaging what I actually type, that this could still happen. But it does. A lot. And the reason is, no matter how many screening processes I set up for myself, whether it’s one more, five more, or hundreds more, sometimes, you’re just not going to know something’s wrong until you actually sit it there on the page. Only then will you go “Oh! No, that doesn’t work, it needs to be this!”
When that happens, I see how far back I’d have to go to make the correction. Because if I’ve written five pages before I noticed the mistake, that fear of derailing my momentum comes into play, and I opt to just make a note of the change that needs to be made when I sit down to do my first round of revisions. But if it’s something that was just typed a paragraph or two before, something I can literally see on the page I’m currently typing, I go back and made the mistake.
So that’s my rule for rewrites. If it’s within the current page I’m working on, I’ll make the quick edit. But if it’s anything longer than that, while I’ll pivot the way I’m telling the story so that it reflects the change I need to make as though I’ve already made it, for the current draft, I’ll merely make a note of it until I’m ready to revisit that part of the story in the next draft.